Hands HR

How To Decide Between Two Job Offers

Introduction

It is a good problem to have, but it is still a problem. You have two offers on the table. One pays more, but the other has a better title. One is a startup, the other is a corporate giant. How do you choose? At Hands HR, we advise candidates to look beyond the paycheck and evaluate the “Total Career Value.”

1. Compare the Total Compensation Package Don’t just look at the base salary. Compare bonuses, health insurance, commute costs, and vacation days. Sometimes, the “lower” salary offer is actually worth more when you factor in benefits and work-life balance.

2. Evaluate Growth Potential Ask yourself: Where will I be in 3 years with Company A vs. Company B? Choose the role that offers mentorship, clear promotion paths, or the chance to learn new skills. A job that stagnates your skills is expensive in the long run.

3. The Culture Factor Think back to your interviews. Where did you feel more comfortable? Which manager did you connect with? You will spend 40+ hours a week here—your happiness matters.

The Hands HR Tip: Create a “Decision Matrix.” List your top 5 priorities (e.g., Salary, Flexibility, Learning, Commute, Brand Name) and rate both companies on a scale of 1-10 for each. The numbers often clarify your gut feeling.

Share this article

Get in touch

Find out more by contacting one of our specialist.

Ready for Your Next Career Move?

Don’t settle for “just a job.” Explore exclusive opportunities with Canada’s top employers and find a role that values your unique skills.